From Second Overall to Last Chance: The Patrik Laine Story

2016 was a banner year for the Canadian NHL teams, depending on your definition of a banner. The Toronto Maple Leafs got the first overall pick, followed by the Winnipeg Jets at 2nd overall, followed by Edmonton, Vancouver and Calgary at 4, 5 and 6 respectively. Montreal and Ottawa didn't face much better selecting 8th and 10th. The picks ranged in success, but all eyes were on Toronto and Winnipeg, and the debate between Auston Matthews and Patrik Laine.

It might seem silly now, as Matthews was named the next captain of the Maple Leafs, while Laine has just been traded for a former third-round pick, and Columbus even had to add a sweetener to do it, but there was a time, where people were seriously debating Matthews vs. Laine.

There are legitimate counterpoints, and I would not fault any team for preferring Matthews. There are risks with Laine. Laine’s lack of complete game and Matthews’ extra season of proving himself — and doing so at an extremely high level — lower the risk on his projection. He could be one of the game’s best players and a centerpiece center for a decade. But I think Laine at the very least has a chance to be something special, and I’d almost always take a chance on special.

In the eyes of some, it came down to as little as Matthews being a centre and Laine being a winger, and if Laine was a centre, there was a good chance he would have been top dog. Either way, it was a debate many people assumed we would be having for years and years to come.

Flying High

And with Laine's first year as a Jet, it looked like the two players were close. In Laine's rookie season, he scored 36 goals and 64 points in 73 games. Pretty close to Matthews' 40 goals and 69 points in 82 games. Matthews got the nod for rookie of the year with the Calder, but who knows if Laine played the full 82 games?

That was the narrative going into the next season, and for his part Laine stepped up again, beating his goal and point total for his rookie year, while playing in all 82 games for the Jets. It was a statistically better year than Matthews, who missed 20 games due to injury, and all seemed to be going the way everyone predicted in 2016.

And who could possibly forget this game? It was a defining moment in Laine's young career. After falling down 4-0 in the second period, on the strength of a hat-trick, Laine and the Jets beat Matthews and the Leafs. The cherry on top was that Laine's hat-trick goal and overtime winner came directly after Matthews had his own breakaway chance, but he was stopped by future teammate Michael Hutchinson.

A big knock against Laine before his drafting was his 200-foot play, being seen as a bit of a one-dimensional offensive player. But he combatted this by being a plus player in his first two seasons and making a fantastic defensive play, but it just took one of the worst offensive decisions in recent memory:

In his second season, Laine even had good numbers in his playoff run, where the Jets made it all the way to the Western Conference Final, where they ran into the first-year Vegas Golden Knights, who beat them in 5 games. But Laine scored 12 points in 17 games.

Unfortunately, that would be the peak of Laine's career for now. His production went down 14 goals and 20 points in the same amount of games. He would also post a much lower -24, and Auston Matthews would start to pull away.

The next year, Laine's goal production went down further, and he missed a good chunk of the season as well. In fact, after his third season, Laine would not be able to play a full season.

Turning Blue

At the same time, a very similar story was unfolding with Columbus and their young centre, Pierre-Luc Dubois. Dubois was taken one place below Laine in 2016 and also had a good start to his career, which had quickly petered out.

It was clear that both young players needed a change of scenery, and so the Jets sent Laine and Jack Roslovic to the Blue Jackets for Dubois and a third round pick. It was a move looking to jump-start both young players careers, and either help push Winnipeg over the hump to further playoff success, or for the Blue Jackets to see any sort of success as a franchise.

To say Dubois time in Winnipeg was tumultuous would be an understatement. His time as a Jet was marred with questions on his output and drive. He would eventually sign a big deal in Los Angeles, only to not make it past one year before being dealt to the Washington Capitals.

Laine's time in Columbus was slightly better, while the team was much worse. The Columbus Blue Jackets have never been a particularly good team, despite all efforts and good drafting. The closest the team has been to good was when they loaded up as a low seed in the playoffs and knocked off the best regular season team of all time in Tampa Bay, and nothing else of note.

Laine's time in Columbus was odd to say the least. He hasn't played more than 56 games in a single season as a Blue Jacket, however, his numbers while he plays have been pretty great. His first full season in Columbus he scored 56 points in 56 games, and was just 3 points below a point-per-game in his next season.

Last season was basically a wash. Laine only played 18 games, due to a myriad of injuries and off ice issues, and it was clear once again that Laine needed a change of scenery.